As we come to the end of another year, weāre kicking off our Year in Review with a look back at some of our top articles from 2024.
1. Lykos Therapeuticsā MDMA New Drug Application Dominated the News Cycle
The developments around Lykos Therapeuticsā MDMA-assisted therapy New Drug Application (NDA), which was submitted in late 2023 and ultimately rejected by FDA in August, dominated our coverage this year.
Lykos started the year as MAPS PBC, but in January announced it had raised a $100M+ Series A and rebranded to the wolf-inspired moniker. Read: MAPS PBC Closes $100m Series A, Rebrands to Lykos Therapeutics (January 5, 2024).
That early excitement gave way to skepticism as early as spring, however, as the Institute for Clinical and Economic Review (ICER) weighed in on the intervention by publishing its draft evidence review in March. ICER, a nonprofit that is primarily interested in determining the cost-effectiveness of healthcare interventions, presented a very critical draft report that went beyond assessing MDMA-ATās cost-effectiveness, taking aim at what it deemed to be fundamental flaws in the design and conduct of the companyās clinical trials. Those fundamental issues, it said, compromised its ability to produce a solid cost-effectiveness model.
ICERās review led to a deluge of bad press for Lykos, tempering widespread optimism surrounding the companyās NDA. We covered the developments through several articles, including:
- ICER Draft Evidence Report on Lykosā MDMA-Assisted Psychotherapy Deems Clinical Evidence āInsufficientā (March 27, 2024)
- Exclusive: Therapists and Trialists from Lykosā Phase 3 MDMA-Assisted Therapy Studies Push Back on ICERās Critical Draft Report (April 29, 2024)
- Industry and Researchers Respond to ICER Report on MDMA-Assisted Therapy, Which Maintains Lykosā Clinical Evidence Is āInsufficientā (May 14, 2024)
Then came the FDAās advisory committee (AdComm). We were the only outlet to provide live coverage of the meeting, clocking in at 8,000 words:
- Live Coverage: FDA Advisory Committee Reviews MDMA-Assisted Therapy for PTSD (June 4, 2024)
- See also, PĪ±+ Analysis: FDA Advisory Committee Snubs MDMA-Assisted Therapy for PTSD in Overwhelming āNoā Vote (June 11, 2024)
Two months later, the FDA shared its own negative verdict with Lykos:
Since that decision, we have published many articles providing further analysis of the situation and the path forward, including:
- We covered the companyās layoffs, Rick Doblinās board resignation, and the roping-in of āpharma veteransā. PĪ±+ Breaking: Lykos Lays Off 75% of Staff, Ropes In Pharma Veteran, Doblin Resigns Board (August 15, 2024)
- Our two-parter explored what the FDA might expect from Lykosā next Phase 3 study, according to those familiar with the FDAās complete response letter (CRL). PĪ±+ What Does FDA Expect from Lykosā Next Phase 3 MDMA Study? (Part 1, Part 2) (August 22, 2024)
- We scored an exclusive interview with David Hough, one of the āpharma veteransā brought in to prepare Lykos for a resubmission, once it became clear it planned to play ball with the agency rather than challenge its decision to issue a CRL. PĪ±+ Exclusive: David Hough on Lykosā Path to Resubmission (September 4, 2024)
2. The Obscure Advisory Panel that Blocked Psychedelic Research in California
In January, we broke the news that an obscure advisory panel was blocking dozens of psychedelic studies in California, despite those projects having clearance from the FDA, DEA, and Institutional Review Boards.
The panel, called the Research Advisory Panel of California (RAP-C) (often derisively referred to by the acronym of its earlier name, āCalifornia Research Advisory Panelā (CRAP)) must review all in-state studies involving Schedule I or II substances, or those which investigate a potential substance use disorder treatment. Of course, that means all psychedelics studies fall under the remit of the panel.
RAP-C hit a stalemate in 2023 after the stateās Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act caused issues for commercial study sponsors, who did not wish to have their studies discussed so publicly. That brought the panel to a total halt, and thus the approval of new studies were in limbo.
Our deep dive provided an overview of the panel, the impasse, and what it meant for psychedelic study sponsors and investigators. Our reporting was picked up by the LA Times and other outlets, and a Bill introduced early in the year was ultimately approved by Governor Gavin Newsom in July, ending the deadlock.
Read: The Obscure Advisory Panel Blocking Dozens of Psychedelic Studies in California (January 9, 2024).
3. Our Interview with Ex-FDA Psychedelics Expert Javier Muniz
In early December, our Editor Josh Hardman sat down with Javier Muniz, MD, who had recently left his post as Associate Director at the FDAās Division of Psychiatry. There, he was at the heart of the agencyās psychedelics learning journey and helped formulate its view on thorny topics in psychedelic drug development like functional unblinding and the role of psychotherapy.
The interview was far-reaching, beginning on topics like FDAās psychedelics-related trip of discovery, which includes Michael Pollanās best-selling book but also standing-room-only presentations at conferences, before diving into some of the specific challenges that psychedelic drug developers face and how Muniz, and the FDA, might think about them. Those include managing functional unblinding, demonstrating durability of effect, understanding the role of psychotherapy, and more. We also had Muniz weigh in on whether the agency has a higher bar for psychedelic programmes, if he thinks Janssenās esketamine nasal spray (Spravato) would be approved today, and why Lykos Therapeuticsā MDMA-assisted therapy new drug application (NDA) was not approved earlier this year.
Aside from these more regulatory-minded topics, we also discuss Munizās views on mystical experiences (and whether their intensity makes attempts to blind psychedelics studies futile), decriminalisation and legalisation efforts, what the incoming Trump administration might mean for the field, and much more.
The interview is extensive, and our longest one yet at well over 7,000 words.
Read: PĪ±+ Inside the FDAās Psychedelics Journey: Javier Muniz, MD on Breakthroughs, Challenges, and the Future of the Field (December 5, 2024).
Stay Informed in 2025 with PĪ±+
Subscribe to PĪ±+ to receive all of our Bulletins, deep dives and analysis, as well as access to the PĪ±+ Library and other subscriber-only content.
Your subscription goes directly toward supporting our coverage, not glossy graphic design or marketing budgets. Learn more and subscribe here, or get in touch to discuss team plans.
Ready to subscribe to PĪ±+? Choose a monthly or annual plan by clicking the appropriate button below.
Looking for team/group plans? Email plus@psychedelicalpha.com.
4. European Consortium Scores ā¬6.5 in EU Funds for Psilocybin Study
In January, we reported on news that the European Union (EU) had awarded ā¬6.5 million to support a multi-site randomised controlled trial of psilocybin to ease psychological and existential distress in a variety of progressive illnesses like multiple sclerosis (MS) and chronic obstructive pulmonary disorder (COPD).
According to the grantās recipients, a nineteen-member pan-European consortium dubbed āPsypalā, the award represented the first ever European grant to fund clinical research into psychedelic-assisted therapy.
Earlier this month, the group announced that the study has been authorised, with conditions, in the relevant EU member states, and German medical cannabis company Avextra was recently announced as the supplier of the study drug. Psypal hopes to begin recruiting patients in 2025.
Read: European Union Grants ā¬6.5M for Multi-Site Psilocybin Study in Palliative Patients (January 24, 2024).
5. MindMedās āTotal Eliminationā of Psychotherapy
In March, LSD drug developer MindMed scored an FDA breakthrough therapy designation for its LSD-D-tartrate candidate (MM120) in the treatment of generalised anxiety disorder (GAD). The company recently announced that it has dosed the first patient in its Phase 3 program studying the same intervention.
Notably, the company and its executives have been keen to emphasise the absence of āpsychotherapyā from its protocol. As we explored here, however, debates around what constitutes āpsychotherapyā and āpsychotherapeutic interventionā are increasingly salient among psychedelic researchers, practitioners and drug developers. These debates are exacerbated by a lack of a commonāor at least consensusālanguage or delineation of these terms.
Thereās also the matter of different audiences: while researchers and practitioners might be appealing to their colleagues, drug developers are often looking to couch their protocols in a way thatās familiar or attractive to regulators and investors: both of whom might prefer an approach, or communiquĆ©, that emphasises drug effect.
Here, our Editor Josh Hardman spoke with people close to the study as well as MindMed representatives including CEO Robert Barrow to look at the protocol employed in the Phase 2b study. Beyond this particular study, the article touched on some of the broader debates around psychotherapy in psychedelic treatment protocols, MindMedās regulator-friendly rhetoric and commercial positioning, as well as what these treatments might look like in a post-approval world.
Read: PĪ±+ MindMedās āTotal Eliminationā of Psychotherapy in LSD Study Stokes Debate Around Its Role in Psychedelic Therapies (April 5, 2024).
6. Psychedelics Under Trump 2.0
Since the November U.S. elections, our coverage and analysis of what a second Trump administration might mean for the psychedelics field has begun to take shape.
Thus far, we have assessed where the incoming administration might land on matters related to psychedelic drug development and policy reform, as well as how Trumpās specific picks for health-related roles might influence this future, including:
- Tripping Over Trump: Will the New Administration Embrace Psychedelic Exceptionalism or āJust Say Noā? (November 14, 2024)
- PĪ±+ Psychedelic Drug Development Under Trump 2.0: Health Nominees Signal Uncertain Future (November 30, 2024)
- PĪ±+ Psychedelics Insidersā Trump 2.0 Wishlist (December 10, 2024)
7. AbbVie Inks Deal with Gilgamesh
In May, we shared the breaking news that AbbVie had become the latest large pharmaceutical company to dip its toes into the neuroplastogen research and development field, announcing the most substantial foray of its kind via a deal with a potential value of up to just shy of two billion dollars.
But AbbVie was keen to distance itself from the word āpsychedelicā. Indeed, a representative from AbbVie reached out to Psychedelic Alpha shortly after we published our article to clarify that the collaboration āis focused on the research and discovery of next-generation neuroplastogens, which are a distinct, novel class of compoundsā that āare well-differentiated from psychedelics in that they are not expected to elicit any hallucinogenic or dissociative effectsā.
Still, many investors and operators on the drug development side of the field saw the announcement as a bullish signal, even if it did raise the question of whether incumbents might only be willing to support these types of next-gen, low- or no-trip, programs.
Read: PĪ±+ AbbVie Inks Deal with Gilgamesh Pharmaceuticals (May 13, 2024).
8. NIDA Awards $15M to Psilocybin for Opioid Use Disorder Study
In late October, we shared the news that NYU psychedelic researcher Michael Bogenschutz had scored a $15M grant from the National Institute on Drug Abuse (NIDA) to support a phase 2 clinical trial of psilocybin in the treatment of opioid use disorder (OUD).
Bogenschutz is collaborating with Carey Turnbullās non-profit psilocybin drug development outfit, B.More, which hopes to parlay the resulting data into a full-blown drug development push, with FDA approval the ultimate goal.
We spoke to the pair to learn more about the ambitious NIDA-backed study.
Read: PĪ±+ Backed by $15m in NIDA Funding, NYU and B.More Team Up to Trial Psilocybin for Opioid Use Disorder (October 31, 2024).
9. Google Co-Founder Sergey Brin Backs Ibogaine Drug Developer Soneira
In July, we wrote about how Google co-founder and psychedelics dabbler Sergey Brin looked set to fill $15M of a $25M round by ibogaine biotech Soneira Bio, which hopes to develop the drug for traumatic brain injury (TBI).
In our coverage we explored the foundational work of Soneira, including Nolan Williamsā observational study of magnesium-ibogaine therapy in thirty Special Operations Forces veterans at Ambio Life Sciencesā centre in Mexico. We also looked at questions surrounding the companyās patent filings, which we had previously covered in March.
The news was welcomed by the psychedelic biotech and investor classes, which were on something of a roll as this news came just months after the AbbVie-Gilgamesh deal was announced.
But the Soneira and Gilgamesh deals are very dissimilar, with the former focused on the development of a subjectively and physiologically potent psychedelic and the latterās newfound partner (AbbVie) making it very clear to Psychedelic Alpha that it was only interested in its subjectively muted neuroplastogens. (Gilgamesh does retain its own ibogaine drug development program, though, with its candidate expected to retain the drugās potent subjective experience.)
Read: PĪ±+ Brin Backs Soneira, But Patent Questions Loom Large (July 26, 2024).
10. PSFCās $130M Roadmap to Shape the Future of Psychedelic Philanthropy
In December, we shared a deep dive into the Psychedelic Science Funders Collaborativeās (PSFC) 74-page roadmap document, which calls for $130M in collective philanthropy over the next three years for the field of āpsychedelic-assisted careā.
PSFC is an influential organisation when it comes to psychedelic philanthropy, and thus the field more broadly. But some in the field have raised questions over its lack of transparency and its role in picking a small number of nonprofits to channel large sums of philanthropy towards, with just nine organisations set to receive the vast majority of the $130M itās earmarked.
Read: PĪ±+ SCOOP: PSFCās $130M Roadmap to Shape the Future of Psychedelic Philanthropy (December 20, 2024).
11. European Medicines Agencyās Psychedelics Workshop
In April, we shared a dispatch from the European Medicines Agencyās āmulti-stakeholder workshopā in Amsterdam, which explored diverse matters related to psychedelic trial design and drug development.
In some cases, the workshop felt like a listening session for listeningās sakeāas if to make stakeholders feel heard. But while EMAās tenor felt somewhat prescriptive or rigid at times, its representatives were keen to highlight that āearly dialogueā between sponsors and the agency is very importantā¦ though only sponsors could comment on how useful that dialogue has been.
But even in the case of an EMA approval, the larger question might be: (how) are psychedelic drug developers incentivised to navigate the EU and its member statesā complex landscape to realise a successful commercialisation of a psychedelic therapeutic? Perhaps only time will tell.
Read: PĪ±+ Insights from the European Medicines Agencyās Psychedelics Workshop: A PĪ±+ Dispatch (April 23, 2024).
Stay Informed in 2025 with PĪ±+
Subscribe to PĪ±+Ā to receive all of our Bulletins, deep dives and analysis, as well as access to the PĪ±+ Library and other subscriber-only content. Ready to subscribe to PĪ±+? Choose a monthly or annual plan by clicking the appropriate button below.
Looking for team/group plans? Email plus@psychedelicalpha.com.
